An
Analytical Study of Social Determents of Health
Rathi, H.B.1*, Viswnadham K.K.2 ,
John Masih3
1Dr. Ulhas Patil Medical College and Hospital, Jalgaon
Kh.(MS)
2Department of Paediatric, Govt. Medical College,
Jagdalpur (Bastar) C.G.
3Department of Medicine,
Govt. Medical College, Jagdalpur (Bastar) C.G.
ABSTRACT:
Back Ground: Social factors have a far reaching impact on health
and disease of the community and its members. Matters like nutrition, child
rearing and bearing practices, personal hygiene, seeking timely medical aid,
utilization of govt. health facilities, gender bias, standard of sanitation
etc. are some of the examples where their influence can be easily seen or felt.
Objective: What are various social determents which have an impact on the health
of community?
Participants: Adult residents of both sexes belonging to all
religion of an urban slum.
Variables: Lack of awareness, Religion, Nutrition, Tradition and culture, Lack of
motivation, Obstacles and Miscellaneous.
Material and Methods: In this study, a broad approach "situational
analysis" of operational research was used by interviewing the sampled
population. The most appropriate answer was considered for interpretation of
results.
Observations and Discussions: Non scientific ,undesirable ,age old ,deep
rooted ,traditions believes and culture because of lack of awareness were found
responsible for this sorry state of affairs of health of the community. For
combating the unearthed reasons there is an urgent need to bring about change
in knowledge, attitude and practices of the people through applying the
technique of de-education and re-education. For this, a wise use of media mix
i.e. modern and traditional media will yield positive results. Educating women
is a tested solution for the treatment of all the ills of society, hence no
stone left unturned to achieve this noble task of educating the women
KEYWORDS: Media –Mix, Telemedicine-health, Jan-Bhagidari.
INTRODUCTION:
Why people who need
a particular service are least likely to use it or fail to take full advantage
which is supposed to take? A case in point is sanitation. A decadal census of
household amenities and assets revealed that standard of sanitation could have
been better. Mihir Shah, planning commissioner, and member in-charge of rural
development, admitted that the approach of providing sanitation was flawed. We
have tried to build toilets for all without ensuring quality resulting many of
them remaining unused (1). Similarly low accesses to government facilities in
up lifting the living standard of people at the base of pyramid (2),
underutilization of various national health programmes viz. reproductive and
child health programme, gender bias, Child marriage, Child labor, improvement
of dietary pattern etc. have all proved abortive or only partially successful.
Taking in to
account the above facts and as per recommendations of the World Health
Organization (W.H.O.) study group in 1957,that in order to get a comprehensive
picture of a disease or health related matter, more and more such studies have
to be carried out, Garg Narenra K.(3) and Garg Narenra K. and Sharma A.B.(4),
the authors have under taken this study with the objective to find out the
cultural factors and social relations in connection with illness and the social
principles in medical organization and treatment. Taking in to account the
above facts and as per recommendations of the World Health Organization
(W.H.O.) study group in 1957,that in order to get a comprehensive picture of a
disease or health related matter, more and more such studies have to be carried
out, Garg Narenra K.(3) and Garg Narenra K. and Sharma A.B.(4), the authors
have under taken this study with the objective to find out the cultural factors
and social relations in connection with illness and the social principles in
medical organization and treatment.
MATERIAL AND METHODS:
This study was undertaken in an urban slum of Nagpur
city (M.S.).This being a slum area, the houses were mostly kachha. Residents of
slum were taking water from public well and corporation taps, the supply was
interrupted. There were very few public latrines but not in use. Majority of
people belong to low socio-economic category, most of them were working as
laborers. An urban health centre, govt. aaurvedic hospital/dispensary, mobile
health clinic and private practitioners were situated in and around the slum
that were in sufficient in fulfilling the health needs of the residents.
In this study, a broad approach "situational
analysis" of operational research (5 and6)was used by interviewing the
adult sampled population of both sexes belonging to all religion viz. Hindu,
Muslims, Sikhs, Christians, Boddha etc. The relevant reply from the respondents
was recorded in their own words and has been classified in six headings and sub
headings (7).
OBSERVATIONS AND DISCUSSIONS:
The data thus collected were analyzed and
interpretation was drawn accordingly.
(1).Lack of awareness:
(a).Fear of side effects of
allopathic medicine-not taking in full course or in doses as per prescribed by
the consulting "Chikistak", leading to resistance of drugs or desired
effects were not achieved.
(b)Family Planning-
(i).Male Sterilization –lead
to lack of libido etc.
(ii)Female Sterilization
–-Obesity / Backache-may lead to lack of morality in the society
(iii).Cu.-T, -Backache-heavy
menses etc.
(c).Nutrition –
(i).Nutrition during pregnancy--less
diet otherwise baby will be heavy which may lead to difficulty in delivery,
hence mother is deprived of proper nutrition and both mother and child become
anemic.
Papaya causes abortion hence papaya is not offered to
pregnant woman hence there are chances of Vitamin-A deficiency.
(ii).Adolescent girls take less diet to remain slim may
lead to be anemic.
(iii).Ghee-Keep the mind cool, sharpen memory and
increase intelligence
(iv).Egg – cholesterol which may cause heart problems/
heat up the body.
(v).Jiggery – heat up the body
(vi).Buffalo Milk – blunt intellectuality.
(vii).Diet during illnesses specifically during fever-
rice is not taken because rice increases fever.
(viii). Costlier fruits provide more energy/nutrition.
(2).Religious :
(a)Fasts – in some religion fasts are advocated - too
many fasts weaken the body.
(b)Family Planning –
(i)Children are gift of "God".
(ii)Every man has to be married and every couple must
have a son.
(c)Diet –specifically non-vegetarian diet not advocated
in some religion.
(d).Child Marriage –-marriages are fixed in heaven. -
Girl must be married even before starting of menses to earn "Punya".
(e) Illnesses is because of our past sins.
(f) Measles/chicken pox is the result of
"Goddess" is not pleased.
(3) Lack of motivation :
(a) To seek early health care.
(b) To take full course of medicine as per prescription
of the "Chikishak".
(c) Lack of faith in one system of treatment
specially"Allopathic" resulting patient frequently changes the system
–from allopathic to aayurvedic / traditional unscientific system of cure
viz.Jhaad-phook /Jaadoo-tona/Ganda-taaviij/ Kala-teeka to protect from evil eye
etc.
(d) Rumors- specially at govt. health facilities-
(i). about quality of medicine
(ii).Lab investigations
(iii).Behavior of health personnel.
(4) Obstacles
–
(a) Insufficient health facilities /situated far away.
(b) Rush or health personnel were not reaching in time
particularly in govt. health facilities, patients have to wait for long time.
(c) In sufficient medicine / equipments etc.
(d) Time inconvenient because of pre engagement of the
community personnel.
(5)Traditions and Culture :
(a) First feed of new-borne – Honey/Glucose water / Some
"Ghuti" etc.
(b). Initiation of breast (mother) milk to new borne
after "Chhati" (8).
(c) Feeding of just delivered mother –not properly fed
because it may cause some problem to new borne.
(d).Weaning- weaning was not done as per recommended
time generally too late and food was not as per recommendations, just giving
Biscuits etc.
(e).Cooking specially washing of rice too much time
taken for washing rice resulting water soluble vitamins washed away.
(f). Pulses –specifically Arhar- Dhal -is consumed
because it was a tradition coming from generation to generation.
(g).Men eat first –women in the last.
(h) Toilets were built for the community but remaining
unused because there was tradition to go to open field for defecation, thus
providing sanitation was flawed.
(6).Miscellaneous :
(a).Discrimination in bringing up of children on
account of sex (9),
(b).Domestic violence.
(c).Negligence of women in health care.
(d).Indiscriminate use of drugs specially pain killers.
(e).Pressure of Peer groups for do or do not.
Modern India continues to be plagued by social and
health ills like child marriage, early mother hood and domestic violence.
Latest data in the state of the world's children report-2012 released by UNICEF
shows that almost 22% women in India now aged between 20 and 24 years gave a
birth to a child before turned 18 (10).
Almost 45 among every 1000 children are born to mothers
in the 15-19 age brackets. Shockingly, around 57% of male adolescents (aged
15-19) and 53% of female adolescents thought a husband was justified in beating
up their wives under certain circumstances.
Around two in four people in urban India and one in
five in rural settings used improved sanitation facilities. Almost one in three
newborns is borne with a low birth weight, with less than 50%children being breast
fed by their mothers. A child born in a slum in urban India is as likely to die
before the first birth day, to become under weight or anemic or to be married
off before the18th birth day as a child in rural India. Un fortunately for the
urban poor child, the situation is not as visible and gets diluted by a much
rosier picture of urban life. Great inequities are found within towns and
cities, where great opportunities and great deprivation exists side by side,
Karin Hulshof, UNICEF representative to India (10).
According to UNICEF, more than 40%of the world's child
marriages still occur in India. Worldwide, more than 60 million women between
20 and 24 years were married before they turned 18.
According to the National family health survey, about
10 millions girls are married each year before the age of 18 worldwide –one
third of them live in India. Child marriage is prohibited by law in India
.However ,the latest available government survey found 48%of women (aged 20 and
24) were married or in union before the age of 18 ,and almost one in five was
married or in union before she turned 15 (10).
Indians enjoy a better standard of living than a decade
ago but they are spending on TV sets and mobile phones rather than sanitation,
a decadal census of house hold amenities and assets revealed (1). Mihir Shah,
planning commissioner, member in-charge of rural development, admitted that the
approach of providing sanitation was flawed. We have tried to build toilets for
all without ensuring quality resulting many of them remaining un used.
As many as 92%mothers either don't know of the term
"malnutrition" or are unaware of the fact that poor nutrition causes
more than 50%deaths of children below five years of age in the country.
Malnutrition makes people, especially women and children susceptible to various
diseases (2)."Educating women is a tested solution," said Sir Michael
G Marmot, chair, European review on social determinants of health and health
divide. Experts feel that education will also help eradicate problems such as
lack of awareness, gender bias and low access to government facilities in
uplifting the living standard of people at the base of pyramid.
India's abysmally low doctor-patient ratio, one doctor
for 1,953 people or a density of 0.5 doctors per 1,000 population in comparison
to WHO's recommended norm of one doctor per 1000 people, coupled with acute
shortage of nurses and health delivery personnel is a matter of concern
(11).The Prime Minister's Office (PMO) is pushing for an early introduction and
passage of the National Commission on Human Resources in Health (NCHRH) for
"Building human resources for health by producing adequate number of
doctors, nurses, auxillary nurse midwives, other paramedics in vital" bill
in parliament. The planning commission high-level expert group (HLEG) recently
suggested the setting up of a Public Health Service Cadre that would be
responsible for all public health functions starting at the block level, and
going up to state and national levels.
Delhi recorded one of the lowest death rates in India
in2010 with four out of every 1000 people dying that year. According Union
health secretary PK Pradhan, "Overall ,life expectancy in Indian is
increasing with better nutrition and health care availability "Former
union health secretary K Chandramouli added that "major growth in health
infrastructure – more number of community health centers ,primary health
centers and district hospitals is a major reason .Better emergency care
services also contributed" (12).
Doctors say that more and more youth are self
–medicating and overusing painkillers, unaware of the danger that it can even
take their lives (13).
The study involving nearly 56,000 women with at least
one child concluded that mothers who exclusively breastfed for at least six
months were less likely to develop hypertension over a 14-year period than
those who bottle-fed (14).
Mothers struggling to get their babies to sleep should
consider cutting back on their own caffeine intake. Drinking coffee, tea, soft
drinks and even eating chocolate increases the level of the stimulants in the
mother's blood, which is passed on babies on breast fed, making them sleepless,
restless and irritable(15). Babies cannot remove caffeine from their bodies;
especially in their first two weeks of life. Ideally, new mums should not have
more than 300 mg of caffeine –equivalent to three cups of coffee a day.
For many people, the key question regarding fasting is
whether it's good or bad for health. Now ,a new study says that skipping meals
for a couple of days (one or two days) a week could help a person live longer
because it can protect the brain against Alzheimer's, Parkinson's and other
degenerative brain conditions(16).
Researchers at the University Hospital in South
Manchester in Britain put 115 women volunteers on one of three diets for the
study. The first involved sticking to just 650 calories a day for two days of
the week, including cutting out carbohydrates such as pasta, bread and potatoes
and all fatty foods. For the other five days, they could eat as much as they
liked, although they were encouraged to stick to healthy foods. Women on the
second diet were also banned from carbohydrates for two days of the week but
they did not have a specific calorie limit .They could also eat as much as they
wanted the rest of the week. The third group followed a standard weight-loss
diet, which involved sticking to about 1,500 calories every day and avoiding
high –fat foods and alcohol. They found that women who stuck to fruit, vegetables
and lean meat for two days a week while being allowed to eat as much as they
liked on other days lost nearly twice as much weight than those on the
full-time diet (17).
Women, better multi-taskers in comparison to their male
counter parts (18), in spite of this there are reports of gender bias and even
domestic violence.
The findings of the present study were more or less in
accordance of the findings of different studies conducted across the globe by
different authors and national and international organizations like WHO and
UNICEF etc.
Popcorn –seems to be the latest "nutritional
golden nugget". Scientist report popcorn, which is a 100% unprocessed
grain, contains more of the highly healthy antioxidant substances called
polyphenols than fruits and vegetables if it is not dipped in butter, oil or
salt. The hulls of popcorn –the part that everyone hates for its tendency to be
caught in the teeth –has been found to have the highest concentration of
polyphenols and fiber. The levels of polyphenols rivaled those in nuts and were
up to 15 times greater than whole grain tortilla chips. Joe Vinson from the university of Scranton in
Pennsylvania, who has been pioneer in analyzing healthful components in
chocolate, nuts and other common food items ,presented these findings at the
American Chemical Society's (ACS) Scientific society on Sunday (25-03-2012)
said one serving of popcorn will provide more than 70%of the daily intake of
whole grain needed by an adult. The scientist further added "Popcorn may
be perfect snake food .It is 100% unprocessed whole grain as against all other
grains which are actually processed and diluted with other ingredients –meaning
only 51% of the product is whole grain. The average person only gets about half
a serving of whole grains a day and popcorn could fulfill that gap in a very
pleasant way"(19). Vinon however cautioned the finding should not make
people give up fruits and vegetables."Popcorn cannot replace fresh fruits
and vegetables in a healthy diet. Fruits and vegetables contain vitamins and
other nutrients that are critical for good health, but are missing from
popcorn". Vinson explained that the same concentration principle applies
to dried fruit, which holds a polyphenol edge over regular fruit. Another
scientist, Jyoti Arora, head of nutrition at Artemis Health Institute, said
popcorn's high content of fiber makes it nutritious and healthy. Whole grains
like popcorn are high in fiber that helps in relieving constipation and leads
to weight loss, better blood sugar control levels under check.
Telemedicine to boost health services – Skype,
biometrics, M-health (use of mobile phones )and E-health are all set to make
entry in to India's primary health centers (PHC's) and Sub health centers as
the health ministry steps on the gas to go hi-tech."The overreaching goal
is to develop a biometric health information system, which begins with
universal vital registration, is portable and accessible to service providers
and to the families themselves. Based on this foundation, a net work links all
service providers, public and private laboratories and also generate figures at
different levels for policy making as well as generates the alerts needed for
disease surveillance" (20).
From above observations and discussions, the authors
reached to the conclusion that the present efforts are succeeded in bringing
awareness in the community up to some extent but still a lot have to do. There
is a wide gap between the knowledge and practices of the people, sooner this gap
is filled better will be the results. Hence, every effort must be made to
bridge this gap. This is possible among other things by (i)unearthing the
factors responsible for undesirable ,unscientific knowledge of the people by
conducting more and more Knowledge ,Attitude and Practices (KAP) studies .The findings of these studies
will act as pegs on which to hang new knowledge.
For bringing awareness proper use of traditional and
modern medias i.e. media mix will be helpful to reach the target groups. (ii)By
strengthening the democratic alliance of key players viz. the patients, people
around them and service providers. So all these three frankly and freely
exchange their views about fears, concern, prejudices and problems etc. and not
only seek help but also extend their help in whatever form, where ever and when
ever desired. Free medical camps are one of the best means for
operationalisation of the strategy. These camps must organized by "Jan-
Bhagidari", using medico-technical service providers. To facilitate these
camps community contribute by providing volunteers and venue as well as by
publicizing the events /camps (venue, time, and date/day etc.) in the
catchments area. This approach also helps to reduce the stigma attached to
various aspects of disease by providing health education and in early detection
of cases if any. These camps can be organized at low cost and do not need any
additional budget (21)). (iii) Educating
women is a tested solution (2) for the treatment of all the ills of society,
hence no stone left unturned to achieve this noble task of educating the women.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT:
Authors are thankful to Dr. A. K Bansal, Ex-Professor
and HOD, Dept. of Community Medicine, Govt. Medical College, Jagdalpur (Bastar)
for his guidance and encouragement in preparing this manuscript.
REFERENCES:
1. Mihir Shah. Good news from census: Indians
better off, but ignore sanitation; Hindustan Times, New Delhi, March 14, 2012
2. Sir Michael G Marmot : Girl's education must
to tackle malnutrition ,say experts : Hindustan Times, New
Delhi,February,28,2012 .
3. Garg Narendra K.: Evaluation of the impact
of emesis and emesis plus purgation therapy; Research J Pharmacology and
Pharmacodynamics:2 (2) March-April;2010:201-202.
4. Garg Narendra K and Sharma A.B. :
Epidemiological profile of patients attending a tertiary care hospital,
Muktsar, Punjab (India); Research J Pharmacology and Pharmacodynamics:3 (6)
November-December;2011:311-317.
5. Park J.E. : Text Book of Preventive and
Social Medicine (Treatise on Community Health) 1st Edition (1970) ;
M/S Banarsi Das Bhanot, Jabalpur,India:p.p.542-598.
6. Bansal, A.K. and Govila, A.K. ; Quality of
services under ICDS in a rural block : India :J of Ravishankar University :
Vol.10,No. B (Science) 1997: pp 71-81.
7. Bansal, A.K. and Chandorkar, R.K.;
Immunization status of tribal and non tribal children of Raipur district
,Madhya Pradesh; Tribal Health Bulletin (ICMR) 1997 Vol.3 :No.2 pp12-14.
8. Bansal, A.K. and Chandorkar, R.K.;
Knowledge, belief and practice :a study of tribal mothers about feeding of
infants : Tribal Health Bulletin (ICMR) 1993 Vol.2 :No.3and6 pp1-2
9. Karin Hulshof: 22% of mothers under 18,
finds UNICEF study; The Times of India, New Delhi:02-03-2012;pp10.
10. Bansal A.K., Ashok K Agarwal and Govila
A.K.; Status of the girl child amongst tribes and non tribes in the un-reached
rural India: J of Ravishankar University : Vol.11-12,No. B (Science) 1998-99:
pp 31-36.
11. PMO pushing to ramp up poor doc-patient
ratio: The Times of India, New Delhi; 08-03-201 2: pp10.
12. Delhi death rate among lowest; Sunday Times
of India, New Delhi: 12-02-2012; pp06.
13. Painkiller abuse drills holes in teen's
stomach; The Times of India, New Delhi; 20-03-2012..
14. Breast feeding cuts blood pressure risk in
women; The Times of India, December 28, 2011; pp13.
15. Mom's caffeine spikes breast milk; Sunday
Hindustan Times, New Delhi, and February 26, 2012: pp16.
16. Fasting once or twice a week could help you
live longer; The Times of India, New Delhi, February 27. 2012 : pp11.
17. Want to cut flab? Try strict diet for just
two days /week; Sunday Times of India, New Delhi.
18. (18)Barbara Schneider et. al. :Women, Better
Multi-Taskers; Sunday Hindustan Times, New Delhi, December 04,2011:pp16.
19. "Popcorn is healthier than fruits"
packs more punch than veggies with higher antioxidant content : Study ;The
Times of India, New Delhi :28-03-2012; pp-12.
20. Telemedicine to boost health services; The
Times of India, New Delhi :19-03-2012 :pp06..
21.
Bansal
A.K. and Garg Narendra K.: Information, Education and Communication in context
of Reproductive and Child health including H.I.V./AIDS; J. of Ravishankar
Uni.vol.14:No.B (Science)2001; pp.28-34.
Received on 23.03.2012
Modified on 18.04.2012
Accepted on 26.04.2012
© A&V Publication all right
reserved
Research J. Pharmacology and Pharmacodynamics.
4(5): September
–October, 2012, 267-271